Fantasy Football Playoff Challenge Rankings: Tom Brady, Steelers duo top lists (2024)

The regular season might be over, but you can still get your Fantasy Football fix by playing in a playoff challenge throughout the postseason.

Several sites offer a playoff challenge game and we have you covered with player rankings, which can also be applied to daily leagues.

The ideal situation is to find players who play four games (Wild Card round through the Super Bowl), but three games should be the goal. Obviously, the more games they play, the better their overall production, but knowing the rules of your playoff challenge is important.

The first thing you want to do is map out the postseason and figure out who will win in each round. For example, in the AFC, I expect Houston to beat Oakland and Pittsburgh to beat Miami. New England will beat Houston, and Pittsburgh will upset Kansas City on the road. The Patriots will then advance to the Super Bowl over the Steelers in the AFC Championship Game.

The games that could go either way in the AFC are the Raiders and Texans in the Wild Card round and the Chiefs and Steelers in the Divisional Round. I don't have faith in Connor Cook or Matt McGloin to win on the road, which is why I like Houston even with Brock Osweiler or Tom Savage, and I think the Steelers are better than the Chiefs, even in Kansas City. It also wouldn't be a shock if the Steelers reached the Super Bowl as well.

In the NFC, I like Green Bay over the Giants, which is close, and Seattle over Detroit, but then it gets tricky in the Divisional Round. Atlanta should beat Seattle at home, but Green Bay at Dallas can go either way. You can make a strong case for the Cowboys, Falcons or Packers to reach the Super Bowl, but I see the Packers beating the Falcons in the NFC Championship Game.

My Super Bowl prediction before the season was a Patriots-Packers Super Bowl, so I'm sticking with that since both teams are still alive. With that in mind, I'm leaning heavily toward players from Green Bay and New England in any playoff challenge.

But I also like players from the Steelers since they could play 3-4 games, and I'm still leaning on guys from the Falcons and Cowboys in case they play three games as well. Seattle should play two games, and the Giants and Chiefs can also play two games, although I don't expect that to happen.

Most people expect the Lions and Dolphins to lose in the Wild Card round, and whoever wins the Raiders-Texans game should be destroyed the following week at New England. The one certainty about these NFL playoffs is the Patriots have the best chance to reach the Super Bowl.

And we'll see if these predictions lead to Fantasy production for the players throughout the playoffs.

Quarterback

See Also

Fantasy Baseball 2-start pitcher rankings: It's a big week for those going twiceSEC baseball power rankings: How conference race shapes up in final weekWhy the Premier League should adopt playoffs to crown a champion2024 Dream Football Ratings and Forecasts

Tom Brady

TB • QB • #12

2016 regular season stats

CMP %6,740.0

YDS3,554

TD28

INT2

View Profile

1. Tom Brady, Patriots
2. Aaron Rodgers, Packers
3. Ben Roethlisberger, Steelers
4. Matt Ryan, Falcons
5. Dak Prescott, Cowboys
6. Russell Wilson, Seahawks
7. Eli Manning, Giants
8. Alex Smith, Chiefs
9. Brock Osweiler, Texans
10. Matthew Stafford, Lions
11. Matt Moore, Dolphins
12. Connor Cook, Raiders

I struggled with the order for the top five quarterbacks, but I went the safe route with Brady at No. 1 since he should play three games in reaching the Super Bowl. Rodgers, Roethlisberger, Ryan and Prescott all have the chance for three games as well, but Rodgers and Roethlisberger could get four games if they reach the Super Bowl.

Wilson should play at least two games, and Manning could pull off the upset in Green Bay, which puts him at No. 7. Smith could also play two games, but he has minimal upside as a Fantasy quarterback.

Osweiler or Savage are No. 9 since I expect the Texans to play two games, and Stafford and Moore should be done after one week. Cook or McGloin also should play just one game since I expect the Raiders to lose on the road at Houston.

Running back

Le'Veon Bell

TB • RB • #6

2016 regular season stats

ATT261

YDS1,268

TD7

REC75

REC YDS616

REC TD2

View Profile

1. Le'Veon Bell, Steelers
2. LeGarrette Blount, Patriots
3. Ezekiel Elliott, Cowboys
4. Devonta Freeman, Falcons
5. Ty Montgomery, Packers
6. Lamar Miller, Texans
7. Thomas Rawls, Seahawks
8. Spencer Ware, Chiefs
9. Latavius Murray, Raiders
10. Dion Lewis, Patriots
11. Tevin Coleman, Falcons
12. Jay Ajayi, Dolphins
13. Paul Perkins, Giants
14. Rashad Jennings, Giants
15. Zach Zenner, Lions
16. James White, Patriots
17. Charcandrick West, Chiefs
18. Aaron Ripkowski, Packers
19. Alfred Blue, Texans
20. Alex Collins, Seahawks
21. Christine Michael, Packers
22. DeAngelo Williams, Steelers
23. Darren McFadden, Cowboys
24. Dwayne Washingon, Lions
25. DeAndre Washington, Raiders
26. Jalen Richard, Raiders
27. Damien Williams, Dolphins
28. Kenyan Drake, Dolphins

If Bell gets four games in the playoffs then he should be the best Fantasy player in any playoff challenge, which is why he's No. 1. Blount has the chance for three games, and he led the NFL with 18 rushing touchdowns this season, but he won't help you much in any PPR challenge with only seven catches during the year.

It wouldn't be a surprise to see Elliott or Freeman play three games and dominate, and both could easily be better than Blount, especially in PPR. But those first four running backs could be exceptional, especially if all four advance to the Championship Game in each conference.

Montgomery is No. 5 since I expect the Packers to play four games, and I have Miller at No. 6 and Rawls at No. 7 since I expect them to play two games, which gives them the chance for plenty of volume. Ware and Murray could also play two games, so those two guys are next on the list.

Lewis and Coleman are backups who still get plenty of touches, and we've seen both have solid games of late, especially Coleman. And Ajayi was tough to rank because he could easily struggle against the Steelers in the Wild Card round, but he could also have one great game even in a loss at Pittsburgh.

I hope the Giants lean on Perkins over Jennings at Green Bay, and either of these guys could be a steal if the Giants upset the Packers and play at least two games. The same goes for Zenner, who has played well in the past two games for the Lions, but Detroit will likely be eliminated in the Wild Card round at Seattle.

Wide receiver

Antonio Brown

TB • WR • #81

2016 regular season stats

See Also

2024 Fantasy Sports Rankings and you can Forecasts - Phú Nông

TAR155

REC106

YDS1,284

TD12

View Profile

1. Antonio Brown, Steelers
2. Jordy Nelson, Packers
3. Julio Jones, Falcons
4. Julian Edelman, Patriots
5. Dez Bryant, Cowboys
6. Davante Adams, Packers
7. Doug Baldwin, Sehawks
8. Malcolm Mitchell, Patriots
9. Odell Beckham, Giants
10. DeAndre Hopkins, Texans
11. Eli Rogers, Steelers
12. Michael Crabtree, Raiders
13. Amari Cooper, Raiders
14. Tyreek Hill, Chiefs
15. Mohamed Sanu, Falcons
16. Cole Beasley, Cowboys
17. Taylor Gabriel, Falcons
18. Chris Hogan, Patriots
19. Terrance Williams, Cowboys
20. Sterling Shepard, Giants
21. Golden Tate, Lions
22. Jarvis Landry, Dolphins
23. Jeremy Maclin, Chiefs
24. Kenny Stills, Dophins
25. Anquan Boldin, Lions
26. DeVante Parker, Dolphins
27. Michael Floyd, Patriots
28. Geronimo Allison, Packers
29. Jermaine Kearse, Seahawks
30. Randall Cobb, Packers
31. Marvin Jones, Lions
32. Cobi Hamilton, Steelers
33. Will Fuller, Texans
34. Seth Roberts, Raiders
35. Paul Richardson, Seahawks

Brown should have a big game against the Dolphins, and he should be great throughout the playoffs, especially if the Steelers play four games. The same goes for Nelson and Adams if the Packers play four games, and both were top-seven Fantasy receivers in standard leagues during the regular season.

Jones looks to be fine following a two-game absence toward the end of the year with a toe injury, and he could play three playoff games. The same goes for Edelman, who went off in Week 17 at Miami.

Bryant can easily be a top-three receiver in any playoff challenge if the Cowboys play three games, and I like Baldwin's potential in two games as the No. 1 receiver for Seattle. Mitchell was hard to rank since he missed Week 17 with a knee injury, but hopefully he'll be healthy coming off a bye. And it was hard to rank Beckham at only No. 9, but the Giants could easily be one and done in the Wild Card round at Green Bay.

I hope Hopkins does well in potentially two playoff games, but his volume puts him in this spot. And Rogers has come on of late and slots in at No. 11 with the Steelers expected to play at least three games.

The Raiders receivers are tough to trust with Derek Carr (leg) out, and we'll see if Gabriel (foot) is healthy after missing Week 17. I also struggled with Hill since he could be awesome (three touchdowns in his past four games), but he also went two games without a catch over that span and the Chiefs could lose in the Divisional Round.

Tight end

Martellus Bennett

NE • TE • #88

2016 regular season stats

TAR73

REC55

YDS701

TD7

View Profile

1. Martellus Bennett, Patriots
2. Travis Kelce, Chiefs
3. Jimmy Graham, Seahawks
4. Ladarius Green, Steelers
5. Jared Cook, Packers
6. C.J. Fiedorowicz, Texans
7. Jason Witten, Cowboys
8. Eric Ebron, Lions
9. Jesse James, Steelers
10. Will Tye, Giants
11. Dion Sims, Dolphins
12. Ryan Griffin, Texans
13. Luke Willson, Seahawks
14. Richard Rodgers, Packers
15. Clive Walford, Raiders

Bennett has a touchdown in three of his past four games, and he should be the No. 1 tight end in the playoffs if the Patriots play three games. Kelce could challenge him for that spot, but he has to get at least two games for that to happen.

Graham has a great matchup against the Lions in the Wild Card round and the Falcons in the Divisional Round, and he could also challenge for the No. 1 spot on this list. And we hope Green is healthy because of his potential for at least three games, especially in the Wild Card round against the Dolphins, but if he's out then James would get a boost in value.

Cook hasn't been a great Fantasy tight end this year, but his potential for at least three games puts him in this spot. And Fiedorowicz scored in Week 17 at Tennessee, and hopefully he can build on that game against the Raiders in the Wild Card round, especially since he had six catches for 82 yards against Oakland in Week 11.

Witten ranks at No. 7, kind of by default, with the hope he can produce one or two good outings if the Cowboys are able to play at least three playoff games. And Ebron hopefully will play at least one good game in the Wild Card round at Seattle.

Kicker

1. Stephen Gostkowski, Patriots
2. Mason Crosby, Packers
3. Chris Boswell, Steelers
4. Matt Bryant, Falcons
5. Dan Bailey, Cowboys
6. Steven Hauschka, Seahawks
7. Nick Novak, Texans
8. Cairo Santos, Chiefs
9. Sebastian Janikowski, Raiders
10. Robbie Gould, Giants
11. Matt Prater, Lions
12. Andrew Franks, Dolphins

Defense/special teams

1. Patriots
2. Steelers
3. Texans
4. Falcons
5. Seahawks
6. Packers
7. Cowboys
8. Chiefs
9. Giants
10. Raiders
11. Lions
12. Dolphins